Germany is set to make a controversial decision regarding home charging of electric vehicles. Faced with the saturation of the electricity grid, the government is considering limiting the power of private charging stations. This measure, if adopted, could have significant consequences for electric car owners and raises many questions.
An electrical network under pressure
Germany currently has more than 50,000 public charging stations for electric cars. The country has committed to installing an additional one million stations by 2030, in response to increasing sales of electric vehicles. However, this ambitious goal is colliding with a worrying reality: the capacity of the German electricity grid is under strain.
The country's electricity operators have alerted the government to the significant overloads that the network is experiencing at certain times. The combination of electric vehicle charging at public and private terminals, the use of heat pumps to heat homes, and consumption by businesses is leading to excessive energy demand. This situation threatens to cause major problems for consumers.
A controversial measure in preparation
To address this critical situation, the German government is considering a measure that is likely to cause controversy among electric car owners. The idea would be to limit the charging power of private charging stations, without informing owners, while preserving public charging facilities.
This approach raises several questions. First, why target only private terminals and not public ones? Second, how long would this limitation, called “forced throttling” by the Germans, last? Sources mention a maximum duration of two hours, but this raises a third question: to which time slot would this restriction apply?
Consequences for users
German experts estimate that home (wall) chargers support charging powers of 3.7, 7.4, 11 and up to 22 kW. The government is reportedly considering limiting the power of home chargers to 3.7 kW. This decision would have significant implications for charging times:
– A 30-40 kWh battery would take about 10 hours to fully charge.– A 111 kWh battery would take 30 hours to reach 80% charge with 3.7 kW power, compared to 8 hours with an 11 kW charger.
The move also raises questions about how operators will adjust their rates. Since charging at home is generally less expensive than at public charging stations, electric vehicle owners could find themselves financially penalized.
A complex challenge for the government
The German government is facing a major challenge. On the one hand, it must ensure the stability of the electricity grid in the face of growing demand. On the other hand, it cannot ignore the legitimate concerns of electric vehicle owners who have invested in home charging systems.
Implementing such a measure would require clear and transparent communication to consumers. Alternative solutions would also need to be considered for owners of long-range vehicles, who would be most penalized by this power limitation.
This situation highlights the challenges facing countries that are encouraging the mass adoption of electric vehicles. Germany, as Europe's leader in the automotive industry, will be closely watched by its neighbors in managing this issue.
The German government’s final decision will have significant implications for the future of electric mobility in the country. It could also influence the policies of other European nations facing similar challenges. The balance between the energy transition and the capacity of existing infrastructure remains a major challenge for years to come.
SRQ Backlot