โ€• Advertisement โ€•

A new sales king in town?

Does the freshly restyled 2024 Kia โ€‹โ€‹Picanto have what it takes to dethrone the Fiat 500, the undisputed queen of urban sales? Our detailed...
HomeWatchesWhich device to choose for seniors: medical alert systems or smartwatches?

Which device to choose for seniors: medical alert systems or smartwatches?

Ensuring the well-being of our seniors is a daily priority, especially when we canโ€™t be by their side. Learn how medical alert systems and smartwatches can support the safety and health of your elderly loved ones.

Medical Alert Systems for Seniors

Medical alert systems are designed to monitor a person's physical integrity in real time. In the event of an emergency, these devices can be activated manually (by pressing a button) or automatically (using intelligent detection algorithms). Once activated, they immediately connect the user to a medical center where trained professionals provide the necessary assistance, from simple instructions to sending emergency personnel to the scene.

Key Features of Medical Alert Systems

  • Easy to use: Just one button to get immediate assistance in an emergency.
  • Simplified design: Focused only on key functions like emergency alerts, without complicated features.
  • Intuitive: Easy to learn and use, increasing acceptance of this technology by seniors.
  • Continuous Monitoring: 24/7 real-time monitoring by a professional emergency center.
  • Reliable Connectivity: Integration of cellular, Wi-Fi and GPS technologies for reliable communication.
  • Fall Detection: Automatic fall detection and emergency center alert (available on some systems).
  • These features make medical alert systems a valuable technology for seniors, providing independence and peace of mind to them and their caregivers who know their loved ones are being monitored around the clock.

    Smartwatches for Seniors

    Smartwatches are wearable devices that fit on the wrist and integrate all the electronic components needed to provide functionality similar to a mini-computer. Thanks to their sensors, they can not only tell the time but also track health and fitness metrics such as heart rate, activity level and blood oxygen levels.

    key features of smartwatches

  • Wireless communication: Bluetooth connection to a smartphone to transfer the collected data.
  • Emergency features: Some watches have built-in SOS emergency and fall detection features, allowing you to contact a loved one in case of need.
  • Communication: Receive notifications, read and send messages, and even make calls right from the watch.
  • Smartwatches are particularly useful for active and health-conscious seniors, offering additional features like communication and fitness and health tracking.

    Medical Alert Systems vs. Smartwatches: Key Differences

    Features Medical Alert Systems Smartwatches Emergency activation One-button push (manual) or fall detection (automatic) Touchscreen interface, requires built-in app Primary function Immediate emergency assistance Communication (calls, messages) and health tracking (heart rate, SpO2, activity) Fall detection Most with subscription Some devices may have it Monitoring 24/7 monitoring by professional emergency centers Self-monitoring or limited monitoring Emergency response Direct connection to an emergency monitoring center Emergency calls/messages with smartphone Water resistance Often waterproof for use in the shower Varies by model, some are waterproof Battery life Long (days to weeks) Requires daily charging Geolocation (GPS) Yes Yes Operating range Works anywhere (cellular, Wi-Fi, GPS) May require smartphone for communication Health tracking parameters Heart rate (some) and movement (including fall detection) Heart rate, electrocardiogram (ECG), activity, heart rate blood oxygen (SpO2), respiratory rate and sleep tracking Cost Subscription with initial equipment cost One-time purchase with optional data plans

    Which device should you choose for a senior?

    Choosing between a medical alert system and a smartwatch mainly depends on the specific needs of your senior loved one. If you are primarily interested in monitoring their vital signs, a smartwatch is the right choice. On the other hand, if you are looking to provide immediate and personalized assistance with a simple click, a medical alert system is the preferred option.

    Recommendations for medical alert systems

    Recommended for seniors who:

  • Live alone or have reduced mobility
  • Require constant monitoring
  • Prefer simple technology
  • Have chronic health conditions (mobility or visual, among others)
  • Recommendations for smartwatches

    Recommended for seniors who:

  • Are active and health conscious
  • Want additional features like communication and health and fitness tracking
  • Are comfortable with technology
  • Do not have chronic mobility and/or vision problems
  • Combining the two technologies

    It is not always necessary to choose one or the other exclusively. In fact, it is possible to use both medical alert systems and smartwatches together. This approach allows the senior to monitor and track their health and fitness (smartwatch) while also receiving instant assistance at the push of a button (medical alert system). The best part is that medical alert systems come in different forms, allowing the senior to choose the one that can be combined with the smartwatch (for example, a medical alert system in the form of a necklace).

    Currently, there are medical alert systems in the form of smartwatches, maintaining the simplicity and user-friendliness that are key features of traditional medical alert systems. The medical alert watch also offers additional features such as multi-parameter measurements (user movement, heart rate, fall detection), bringing them closer to the capabilities of traditional smartwatches, thus combining the two technologies.

    Both devices, smartwatches and medical alert systems, offer valuable support to seniors in a unique way. Smartwatches allow multi-parameter health monitoring (heart rate, activity levels, heart rate,

    blood oxygen levels), allowing users to monitor their health and share data with caregivers or doctors. In contrast, medical alert systems provide immediate assistance with a single click, facilitating instant communication with emergency services.

    Combining the two technologies significantly improves safety and health monitoring. This dual approach promotes user independence and confidence while providing peace of mind to caregivers.

    SRQ Backlot